Comparing special-vehicle quotations line by line

Compare two special-vehicle quotations for the same configuration and delivery terms. Check their ratings, evidence, exclusions and commercial terms line by line before comparing totals.

One requirement, two complete offers
  • 01Same chassis, body and equipment scope
  • 02Same inspection and document deliverables
  • 03Same currency, delivery point and validity basis
View the reference imageSpecial-vehicle quotations and configuration sheets arranged for a line-by-line comparison

Special-vehicle quotations and configuration sheets arranged for a line-by-line comparison

Find out what creates the price difference

Two quotations can use similar vehicle names while offering different chassis, body materials, working equipment or release documents. Before deciding whether one is cheaper, put the required items side by side and mark each as included, excluded or unanswered.

An unanswered line is not the same as an exclusion. Ask the supplier to price or define it in a revised quotation. Keep that revision with the approved specification so a later discussion of the total does not quietly reintroduce an earlier scope.

Give suppliers one RFQ and a place to state exceptions

A useful request for quotation identifies the chassis model, engine model, emission standard, wheelbase and gross vehicle weight. Add the payload capacity, body dimensions, PTO requirement and hydraulic system duty. Describe optional equipment separately so that a supplier cannot remove it silently to meet a target truck price.

In the quotation comparison, use columns for requirement, offered specification and exception. Keep an empty field visible. A truck procurement decision can change when one offer includes a hydraulic oil cooler, spare parts or commissioning and the other assumes the buyer will arrange them. Ask for written clarification before treating the offers as technically equal.

Which commercial conditions can change the amount payable?

Record the Incoterms rule, named place and version for each offer. EXW, FOB and CIF do not identify the same allocation of tasks and costs. Compare freight cost, marine insurance, inspection cost and destination charges against the actual route; obtain the importer's advice for costs outside the seller's scope.

Record payment terms, quotation validity, warranty terms and the event that starts lead time. Delivery time needs an endpoint: factory release, loading, vessel departure and arrival are different milestones. If a supplier changes a component after quotation, return to the technical specification and cost comparison before accepting the revised total.

Compare the same vehicle and handover point

Work from the complete quotations, including their validity dates. Technical differences belong alongside currency, delivery terms and tax assumptions: a lower chassis specification and a different freight basis can both change the total, but they are different decisions.

Scroll horizontally to view all columns.

Compare the same vehicle and handover point
DecisionWhat to establishCondition or limit
Vehicle identityCompare manufacturer, chassis model, drive, cab and destination configuration.Similar marketing names do not prove an equivalent chassis.
Body and equipmentCompare dimensions, materials, mechanisms, ratings and included accessories.Nominal capacity must not replace working limits or legal payload checks.
Evidence packageCompare drawings, inspection records, test records and release photos.A certificate list is incomplete without scope and applicability.
Commercial basisCompare currency, delivery term, freight, insurance, tax assumptions and validity.Totals on different Incoterm or tax bases are not directly comparable.

Compare two quotations for the same configuration and delivery terms

The two hypothetical offers below include different items. Add the missing costs before comparing them.

Quotation B is lower on the known comparable scope, but neither offer is ready for approval until exclusions and inspection deliverables are reconciled.

Scroll horizontally to view all columns.

Compare two quotations for the same configuration and delivery terms
StepCalculation or conditionResult
A comparable total80,000 + 6,000 + 7,50093,500 USD
B comparable total84,500 + 6,00090,500 USD
Open itemsComparable total + priced missing scopeDecision remains pending
  • Quotation A: Vehicle 80,000 + options 6,000 + freight 7,500 USD
  • Quotation B: Vehicle 84,500 + included options + freight 6,000 USD
  • Missing scope: Inspection and spare-parts package still need confirmation

Illustrative numbers only. Use the same delivery term, tax basis, currency date and approved configuration for real quotations.

Clarify the terms that can change the price

Ask how long the quote is valid and which currency it uses. If an exchange-rate or component-price change can trigger a revision, have the supplier state the trigger and approval process. Do the same for substitutions: a different chassis, pump or control system can affect service support as well as price.

For a fleet order, separate first-unit approval from the remaining production releases. Request the proposed batch sizes, inspection dates and shipping sequence. Capacity, chassis availability and port space are different constraints; a monthly output figure does not reserve a delivery slot.

Normalize the offer before comparing totals

Use the ICC wallchart to check how the selected Incoterms edition and named delivery place allocate delivery responsibilities. Obtain dated quotations or local assessments for the charges you will pay; the trade term does not supply their amounts. Check which charges the vehicle offer already includes so each cost is counted only once. ICC Incoterms 2020 practical wallchart

Scroll horizontally to view all columns.

Keep acquisition charges separate from ownership costs
Cost groupKeep on the same basisRecord inclusion or exclusion
Vehicle and optionsSame signed specification and quantityBody, chassis, equipment, spares and inspection
Transport and handlingSame named delivery place and shipment assumptionsOrigin, freight, insurance, terminal and inland charges
Destination acquisition chargesApplicable import classification and local treatmentDuties, taxes, registration and one-time preparation costs
Operating and lifecycle assumptionsSame work, utilization and ownership periodFuel, service, downtime and residual-value assumptions

ICC Incoterms 2020 practical wallchart

Peru, Mexico and Dominican Republic: separate the document routes

Peru: SUNAT’s public overview distinguishes new from used vehicles and identifies vehicle identity and homologation information for new-vehicle declarations. The undated page retains legacy administrative names. Have the customs agent establish the current requirements for the completed model, importer and proposed regime before relying on it as a checklist. SUNAT vehicle-import documentation

Mexico: identify the completed vehicle or body package, engine family, model year, gross mass and import regime. Confirm the applicable NOM editions, environmental evidence and certification requirements for that configuration. An export record does not establish local approval.

Dominican Republic: DGII version 4.4, section 36, concerns dealers and concessionaires. It lists registration and licensing prerequisites, form FI-VHM-007 and the SIGA customs assessment, and matches chassis data with DGA import information. Check whether that applicant category applies. This document is not evidence that a particular truck obtained a plate. DGII first-plate procedure for dealers and concessionaires

Close the scope before accepting a total

List options separately with their quantities and status. Keep unresolved destination requirements visible, and obtain dated confirmation for freight, exchange-rate and tax inputs. If an offer cannot identify the vehicle or the included work, return it for clarification before treating its total as comparable.

Information to prepare for this review
  • Both complete quotations and validity dates
  • Destination and intended operating mission
  • Required chassis model and destination requirements to confirm
  • Capacity or working-rating requirement
  • Required accessories, documents and inspection evidence
  • Agreed delivery term and handover point
Records to request and keep
  • Signed or revision-controlled quotation
  • Line-level included and excluded scope
  • Project-specific specification or drawing reference
  • Commercial term, handover location and document list
Common mistakes and what to check instead
  • Comparing only the total price: Normalize technical, evidence and commercial scope first.
  • Treating optional equipment as standard: Place every option on its own line with quantity and status.
  • Ignoring unstated items: Record not stated separately from excluded; request a written answer.

Questions before accepting the offer

Should I choose the lowest special vehicle quotation?
  • First establish that the offers meet the same scope and acceptance conditions. Compare the remaining price difference with identified technical, delivery and support differences.
Can I compare a FOB price directly with a CIF price?
  • Normalize the named route, included freight and insurance and the buyer's remaining costs first. Do not add estimated destination costs as though they were confirmed charges.

Scope of this guide

The worksheet does not determine whether a configuration is legally acceptable at destination.

Currency, tax and freight inputs can change and require dated confirmation.

Stop the comparison if either quotation lacks enough identity or scope information to describe the proposed vehicle.

Sources and applicability

ICC Incoterms 2020 practical wallchart

Overview of seller and buyer responsibilities under the selected trade term; does not quote freight, duty or a vehicle price.

Document date:

Sources checked:

SUNAT vehicle-import documentation

Public documentation overview for new and used vehicles. No revision date is displayed and legacy administrative names remain; confirm the current model-specific route with SUNAT and MTC.

Sources checked:

DGII first-plate procedure for dealers and concessionaires

First-plate registration procedure for dealers and concessionaires, including DGA import-data matching. Does not establish vehicle eligibility or a registration outcome for a KEEYAK case.

Version 4.4, section 36, printed pages 57–58

Sources checked:

KEEYAK buying process

Explains the steps from describing the job and comparing quotations to configuration approval and inspection.

Discuss the vehicle you need

Tell us what the vehicle will carry or do, where it will operate and the load you expect. Include any questions you need answered before choosing a configuration.

Discuss your requirements